Gasparilla Island: The Smart Traveler’s Alternative
Pristine beaches, championship fishing, and old-money vibes
Florida
WHY VISIT
While club kids descend on Miami and Key West, the state’s Gulf coast lures couples and families drawn to powdery, shell-strewn beaches and turquoise waters. Of all the barrier islands stretching from the Everglades north to Tampa, wealthy little Gasparilla may be the most serene. There are no high-rises, stoplights, billboards, or fast-food restaurants, and people cruise the old-timey village of Boca Grande by bicycle or golf cart. Celebrity visitors tend to be conservative types. Case in point: The George W. Bushes have been regulars for years. It’s the kind of place where the day’s big excitement might be a croquet game, fish chowder on a sunny patio, or hooking a tarpon.
IF YOU GO
Sarasota and Fort Myers are both about 75 minutes from Gasparilla, which you’ll reach via a causeway. Once on the island you can abandon your car and rely on a golf cart or bike to get most everywhere. Accommodations can be hard to come by in winter, especially around the holidays. You may also want to skip hurricane season (August through October). For decent weather and prices, think about visiting in November, April, or May.
Almost all beaches are public, and most people spend their days swimming, snorkeling, and gathering sea glass, shells, and sharks teeth. Sports fishing in the Boca Grand Pass draws serious anglers, and the exhibits in the historic lighthouse are a welcome break from the afternoon sun. Miller’s Dockside, with views of the marina basin, is about as lively as evenings get, and even they close at 9 P.M.
The classic place to stay is the 110-year old Gasparilla Inn, a natty beachside resort whose loyal clientele knows to dress for dinner. (The inn closes annually from mid-July to October.) For a more barefoot experience, there’s a good pool of rental properties, including condos at the Boca Grand Club, right on the beach. Want an even quieter vacay? To reach Little Gasparilla Island you take a boat from Eldred’s Marina. Once there you won’t find a paved road, a hotel, or a grocery store. There are, however, seven miles of pristine sand. Make-your-own-fun beach bums say it’s heaven.
ONE TRAVELER'S EXPERIENCE
Bob Morris — Writer, fourth-generation Floridian, and president of custom publishing company Story Farm.
“For more than 40 years, our family, seeking distance from the crowds of nearby Sanibel and Sarasota, has made annual pilgrimages to Gasparilla Island, the Gulf Coast outpost we think is more like the Bahamas than anywhere else in Florida. It’s a place that still honors what was once a tradition throughout the state, with many of the shops and restaurants in the island community of Boca Grande (year-round population: 1,840) shutting down in August-September. That’s when it’s possible to walk the seven-mile-long beach, passing only a handful of other people and maybe a few loggerhead turtle hatchlings emerging from nests laid near the dunes.”
DETAILS
Gasparilla Inn — Rates, reservations, and dress codes
Boca Grande Club Rentals — Vacation properties and amenities
Little Gasparilla Island — House rentals and info on wifi, grocery delivery, and other services


